Season 8
Birou Family
- Swiper the Fox plush toy: Orla lost it for decapitating all her sisters' dolls, begging for her treats, hitting her mother with a rolled-up newspaper, biting Jo's hand, and throwing water balloons at the babysitter
- Dora the Explorer coloring book: Orla lost it for calling Jo a horrible person to throw out her treats
- Dora the Explorer DVDs: Orla lost them for behaving unacceptably at the restaurant and the cinemas, and carrying on outside naked
- Princess Jasmine Doll: Orla lost it for pushing her sisters off the trampoline and lying to her mother about it
- Fisher Price Dora the Explorer Tunes Guitar: Orla lost it for biting the babysitter
- Barbie Doll: Orla lost it for hitting the babysitter
- Toy firetruck: Orla lost it for spitting in the babysitter's face
- Cabbage Patch Doll: Orla lost it for hitting her mother in the lip, and flipping the babysitter off
- Dora Swing into Action VHS: Orla lost it for setting the babysitter's ferrets free
- Toy Ice Cream truck: Orla lost it for spitting on her mother
- Barbie Volkswagon Beetle: Orla lost it for going in it with no permission
- Lego Duplo Blocks: Orla lost them for biting her twin sister
- Crayons: Orla lost them for scribbling some naughty words and drawing a picture of someone resembling her mother being murdered by a steamroller with them on the walls
Sanderman Family
- Orange duck plush: Tony lost it for hitting Roberta
- Teddy Ruxpin plush: ??? lost it for
Irine Family
- iPod Touch: Haley lost it for using bad language.
Langbroek Family
- Handy Manny DVDs: Bryce, Teddy and Sherman lost them for misbehaving in school, behaving unacceptably at the posh restaurant
- Barney DVDs: Bryce, Teddy and Sherman lost them for their bad behavior
- Play car: ??? lost it
- Handy Manny toys: ??? lost them
- Puzzles: Bryce, Teddy and Sherman lost them for refusing to get dressed for church
- Barney toys: Bryce, Teddy and Sherman lost them for running away to their friends' houses to avoid going to church when they are supposed to be in timeout
- Barney plush: ??? lost it
- Rolie Polie Olie DVDs: Bryce, Teddy and Sherman lost them for stealing money from the collection basket at church
Season 9
Wailems Family
- Nintendo 3DS: Kyle lost it for being very rude to Nanny Jo
- Draculaura Doll: Lola lost it for smacking her mother and swearing
- Ghoulia Yelps Doll: Lola lost it for breaking her mother's iPod
- Dora the Explorer Doll: Lola lost it for pouring orange juice on her mother's computer keyboard
- LaLaLoopsy dolls: Lola lost all of them for making a mess in the bathroom
- Tom and Jerry DVDs: ??? lost them
- Epic Mickey game: Kyle lost it for hitting Lola
- Darkwing Duck plush doll: ??? lost it
- Wii Game Console: ??? lost it
- Despicable Me DVD: ??? lost it
Megnet Family
- Muno plush toy: Adrian lost it for knocking things over and for calling his mother mean names
- Elmo doll: Adrian lost it for hurting his sisters' feelings
- Go Diego Go DVD: Adrian lost it for watching it in his mother's bedroom when he's in timeout
- Tom and Jerry DVDs: ??? lost them
Belushi Family
- Bugs Bunny Plush Toy: Teddy lost it for pushing his sister Kadee
- Random toys: Teddy lost them for throwing them on the floor
- Barney and Friends videos: Teddy lost them for watching them in Caleb's bedroom when he's in timeout
Truel Family
- Nerf Vortex Vigilion: Aiden lost it for flipping his mother off
Marxonica Family
- Goodnight Pajanimals DVD: Ashley lost it for throwing a tantrum during a trip to the zoo, because she wanted to go on the carousel again
- On the Go Birthday Giesta Dora doll: Ashley lost it for hitting her father
- Dora See 'N Say juniors talking toy: Inez lost it for not taking a nap
- Sweet Pea Sue plush toy: Ashley lost it for using bad language
- Dora the Explorer doll and 13" Apollo the Dog plush toy: Ashley lost them for yelling at her mother
- Dora the Explorer doll: Ashley lost it for beheading Inez's 13" Squacky doll
Hillsborough-Doggerel Family
- Dora the Explorer toys: Wendy and Orla lost them for throwing balls at Brett and Kadee
- Blue's Clues toys: Nicholas, Bryce, Ainsley, John, Sean and Teddy lost them for throwing balls at Brett and Kadee
- Raggedy Ann doll: Wendy lost it for destroying one of her father's wrestling awards
- Blossom doll: Wendy lost it for bombarding her mother with balls
Zunier Family
- Kai Lan Doll: Veronica lost it for smashing the staircase with a crowbar
- Darkwing Duck plush toy: ??? lost it
- Rub n Color set: ??? lost it
Colliant Family
- Boots the Monkey T.Y. Beanie Baby: Teddy lost it for throwing it at Kristin's head
- Dora the Explorer T.Y. Beanie Baby: Ashley lost it for throwing it at Kristin's gut
- Diego T.Y. Beanie Baby: Bryce lost it for throwing it at Kristin's ankle
- Kai-Lan T.Y. Beanie Baby: Orla lost it for throwing it at Kristin's nose
- Baby Jaguar T.Y. Beanie Baby: Derek lost it for throwing it at Kristin's chest
- Swiper the Fox T.Y. Beanie Baby: Aiden lost it for throwing it at Kristin's arm
- Tolee the Koala T.Y. Beanie Baby: John lost it for throwing it at Kristin's nerve cluster
- Muno T.Y. Beanie Baby: Nicholas lost it for throwing it at Kristin's armpit
- Rintoo the Tiger T.Y. Beanie Baby: Kayla lost it for throwing it at Kristin's airway location
- Hoho the Monkey T.Y. Beanie Baby: Sean lost it for throwing it at Kristin's back leg
- Lulu the Rhino T.Y. Beanie Baby: Wendy lost it for throwing it at Kristin's funny bone location
- Tom and Jerry Tales DVDs: ??? lost them
- Pancake Popple plush: Kayla lost it for knocking over a vase with it.
- Puffball Popple plush: Ashley lost it for destroying Kristin's art project with it.
- Potato Chip Popple plush: Wendy lost it for not listening to her parents.
- Puzzle Popple plush: Derek lost it for peeing on the couch.
Juritin Family
- MP3 Player: Joshua lost it for talking back to his mother
- XBOX 360: ??? lost it
Season 10
Golben Family
- Dora the Explorer Doll: Katelyn lost it for defecating outside the toilet
- Alvin and the Chipmunks DVDs: Tristin lost them for being bad
- All Dogs Go to Heaven DVD: ??? lost it
Verdin Family
- Angry Birds King Pig Plush Toy: Harold lost it for swearing to his mother
- Wreck-It Ralph DVD: ??? lost it
- Pinky and the Brain DVDs: ??? lost them
Winer Family
- Big Bird 14" Plush toy: Teddy lost it for hitting his sister Melissa
- Animaniacs DVDs: ??? lost them
Courtiy Family
- Elmo's World DVDs: Mort and Lisa lost them for playing outside in a thunderstorm
- Abby Cadabby plush doll: Lisa lost it for watching Sesame Street: Abby in Wonderland during dinner time
- Super Soaker Monster XL: Mort lost it for ruining Lisa's birthday
- LEGOs: Mort lost them
- Wreck-it Ralph DVD: Mort lost it
- Bolt DVD: Mort lost it
Season 11
- Wreck-It Ralph DVD: ??? lost it
- Darkwing Duck plush toy: ??? lost it
- Elmo doll: ??? lost it
Season 12
Lake Family
- Spongebob Squarepants plush toy: ??? lost it
Simpson Family
- XBOX One games and console: Lester lost it for kicking his mother and for smacking his mother in her face, slitting his wrist and knocking over a potted plant
- Gladiators DVDs: Lester lost them for escaping from the Reflection Room and for spitting on Jo's arm
- PS Vita games and system: Same as Xbox One, Lester lost them for smacking his mother in her face, slitting his wrist and knocking over a potted plant
- Playstation 4 games and console: Same as Xbox One and PS Vita, Lester lost them for smacking his mother in her face, slitting his wrist and knocking over a potted plant
- Wii U games and console: Same as Xbox One, PS Vita, and Playstation 4, Lester lost them for smacking his mother in her face, slitting his wrist and knocking over a potted plant
- iPod Nano: Lester lost it for talking to Jo that way
- Nature book: Eliza lost it for punching Lester in the gut
Finster Family
- Care Bears: Sharpay lost them for disgracing her whole family
- Minnie Mouse plush doll: Sharpay lost it for disgracing her whole family
- Barbie Princess Bride doll: Sharpay lost it for not letting Andi watch Dora the Explorer
- Peppa Pig DVDs: Sharpay lost them for continuing to watch one of them when she's supposed to be in timeout
- Disney Princess Dolls: ??? lost them
Freeling Family
- Barney and Friends DVDs: ??? lost them for
O'Malley Family
- Wings DVD: ??? lost it for
- Kipper DVDs: Logan, Daniel, Nicholas, and Noah lost them for swearing at their mother
Carmichael Family
- Maya the Bee DVDs: Macy-Dawn lost them for watching them when she's supposed to be in timeout
Season 13
Eaglestone Family
- Plankton plush toy: ??? lost it
- Spongebob Squarepants plush toy: ??? lost it
- Gary the Snail plush toy: ??? lost it
- Patrick Star plush toy: ??? lost it
- Squidward Tentacles plush toy: ??? lost it
- Sandy Cheeks plush toy: ??? lost it
- Mr. Krabs plush toy: ??? lost it
Fudger Family
- Strawberry Shortcake's Berry Bitty Adventures DVDs: Angelica lost them for watching them when she's supposed to be in timeout
- Strawberry Shortcake doll: ??? lost it
- Blueberry Muffin doll: ??? lost it
- Plum Pudding doll: ??? lost it
- Orange Blossom doll: ??? lost it
- Lemon Meringue doll: ??? lost it
- Raspberry Torte doll: ??? lost it
- Cherry Jam doll: ??? lost it
- Butterbear plush: ??? lost it
Read Family
- Barney plush toy: Tucker lost it for knocking things over and for calling his mother mean names
- Teletubbies DVDs: Taylor lost them for watching them in his mother's bedroom when he's supposed to be in timeout
Hansen Family
- Draculaura doll: ??? lost it
- Lagoona Blue doll: ??? lost it
- Nintendo 2DS: ??? lost it
- Monster High dolls: ??? lost them
- Bratz dolls: ??? lost them
Winters Family
Hicks Family
- Cell Phone: Marissa lost it for talking to her friends on it during dinner time.
- iPhone: ??? lost it
- MP4 Player: ??? lost it
Panizza Family
- Cell phone: Imogen lost it for arguing with her mother.
- iPod Touch: Imogen lost it for playing music with questionable, explicit lyrics that contained a lot of profanity.
- iPad: ??? lost it
Birou Family Revisited
- Diego plush doll: ??? lost it
- Barney plush doll: ??? lost it
- Toy firetruck: ??? lost it
- Geo plush doll: ??? lost it
- Curious George Matching Game: ??? lost it
- Squacky plush toy ~ Treat lost it for riding on Shamu naked.
- Chutes and Ladders game: ??? lost it
- Angry Birds Black Bird Plush: ??? lost it
- 13" Apollo the Dog plush toy: ??? lost it
- Curious George plush toy: ??? lost it
- 13" Big Bird plush toy: ??? lost it
- Luigi plush: ??? lost it
- Boots the Monkey plush toy: ??? lost it
- Chica the Chicken plush toy: ??? lost it
- 13" Bugs Bunny plush toy: ??? lost it
- Pajanimals coloring book: ??? lost it
- Super Soaker Monster water gun: ??? lost it
- Raggedy Andy doll: ??? lost it
- Elmo plush doll: ??? lost it
- Crayons: ??? lost them
- My Pillow Pets Penguin 18": ??? lost it
- Hide N Squeak Eggs: ??? lost them
- Pikachu plush ~ Brahm lost it for bombarding their dog, Lucy with rocks.
- PSVita: ??? lost it
Season 14
Dale Family
- Crayola Crayons: August lost it for scribbling on the bathroom tiles with them and calling his mother stinky breath
- Curious George Jumbo George 26" plush: Micah lost it for refusing to take a nap and not turning off the TV
- Curious George plush toy: Micah lost it for watching Mickey Mouse Clubhouse when she's in timeout
Olynick Family
- Dora the Explorer toys: Amy and May lost them for not giving Chad back his Nintendo 3DS
- Tom and Jerry DVDs: Amy and May lost all of them for ruining Chad's birthday
Horne Family
- XBOX One: Sam lost it for smashing the fish tank with an aluminum baseball bat
- iPod Nano: Sam lost it for beheading Allyson's Yoshi doll
- Cell Phone: Sam lost it for swearing
Hooyman Family
- MP3 Player: Kelly lost it for playing heavy metal music with questionable, explicit lyrics
- Cell phone: Kelly lost it for playing heavy metal music with questionable, explicit lyrics
- Laptop: Kelly lost it for swearing
- Tiger Beat Magazines: Kelly lost them for swearing
- iPad: Kelly lost them for swearing
Campbell Family
- Elmo plush: Duncan lost it for swearing
- Cookie Monster plush: Jacob lost it for swearing
- Dora the Explorer plush: Clementine lost it for name-calling
- Bob the Builder plush: Yasmin lost it for swearing
- Caillou plush: Akeelah lost it for swearing
- Caillou Sister Rosie plush: Aiden lost it for name-calling
- Little Bill plush: Dakota lost it for name-calling
- Max and Ruby Max plush: Wake lost it for name-calling
Sutton Family
- MP3 player: ??? lost it
- Wii U console: ??? lost it
- Cell phone: ??? lost it
Appleton Family
Gomez Family
Gooch Family
- Rochelle Goyle doll: ??? lost it
- Abbey Bominable doll: ??? lost it
- Big Bang Pegasus Metal Fusion Beyblade: ??? lost it
- Nintendo 3DS: ??? lost it
- Sonny with a Chance DVDs: ??? lost them
- Opretta doll: ??? lost it
Pope Family
- Elmo doll: ??? lost it
Biecker Family
- XBOX One: ??? lost it
- Playstation 4: ??? lost it
- Wii U: ??? lost it
Lucini Family
Remano Family
- XBOX One: Sam lost it for saying (bleep) OFF and purchasing Best Buy items on Bruna's credit card
- Cell phone: Meghann lost it for purchasing Target items on Katarina's credit card
- iPod Touch: Joshua lost it for purchasing guns on his father's credit card
- Cell phone: Rowan lost it for trying to purchase an XBOX 360 on Jo's credit card
- iPad: ??? lost it
- Swiper plush doll: ??? lost it
- Barney plush doll: ??? lost it
- iPhone: Rowan lost it for pouring beer on his parents' desktop computer
- Nintendo 2DS: Meghann lost it for taking a dump in her father's office
- PSP: Sam lost it for throwing his mother's cosmetic kit out the window and slicing Bruna's favorite CD into pieces
- iPod Nano: Joshua lost it for peeing everywhere in Katrina's bedroom
- Nintendo Wii U games: Bryce lost them for refusing to take a nap
- Dora the Explorer doll: Orla lost it for beheading someone's statue on the fizz ball table
Season 15
Moranis Family
- Lisa Simpson plush toy: Christine lost it for torturing her baby sister Luna and for refusing to have dinner with the family.
- Monster High Sweet 1600 Frankie Stein doll: ??? lost it
Allen Family
- Tom Cat plush - Mary-Louise lost it for pushing Shelby off the couch while she was watching One Life to Live and Marie-Louise wanted to watch Saved by the Bell.
- Peppa Pig DVDs - Marie lost them for ruining Lisa's birthday.
- Jerry Mouse plush: ??? lost it
- Tom and Jerry DVDs: ??? lost them
Hennon Family
Grund Family
Frame Family
Burb Family
- Nintendo 3DS ~ Jay lost it for bad behavior
Palmer Family
Pechaluk Family
- Cinderella Doll: ??? lost it
- Snow White doll: ??? lost it
Shuster Family
McLean Family
Hetzel Family
Yang Family
- Bratz Dolls: ??? lost them
- Disney Princess Dolls: ??? lost them
Keaton Family
- Blue's Clues Blue Plush toy: Polly lost it for back-talking and swearing to her mother, Bernice.
- Blue's Clues Arts and Crafts VHS: Polly lost it for watching it in her mother's bedroom when she's in timeout.
Kirochu Family
- Bugs Bunny plush: Anna lost it for being rude by covering her ears and saying "la la la la", calling her mother a horrible person to throw out her treats
- Peppa Pig plush: Anna lost it for decapitating Tariko's Pokemon legendary Azelf plush doll and throwing the Naughty Couch at the babysitter
- Draculaura doll: Anna lost it for hitting her baby niece Ji kwong and for telling the babysitter to shut up
- Snow White Doll: Anna lost it for shoplifting and kicking her brother in the private area
- Tom Cat plush: ??? lost it
- Jerry Mouse plush: ??? lost it
- Rapunzel Doll: Anna lost it for throwing it at Ji woong, yelling at her mother
- Tom and Jerry DVDs: Anna lost them for her unacceptable behavior at the restaurant
- Frankie Stein Doll: Anna lost it for hitting Natasha
- Opretta Doll: Anna lost it for kicking Ji kwong
- Lagoona Blue Doll: Anna lost it for beheading her brother's Halo figure
- Clawd Wolf Doll: Anna lost it breaking her brother's Xbox 360
- Clawdeen Wolf Doll: Anna lost it for shouting and hitting her mother, begging for her treats
- Cleo de Nile Doll: Anna lost it for calling Natasha a Poopy-butt
- Barbie Princess Bride Doll: Anna lost it for shouting and spitting at her mother
- Tom and Jerry Tales DVDs: ??? lost them
- Mongoose Lark Girls' Bike: Anna lost it for saying nasty things to the babysitter
- Princess Ariel Doll: Anna lost it for saying a bad word
- Spectra Vondergeist plush doll: Anna lost it for breaking her brother's stuff
Spoon Family
- Grover plush: Gary lost it for calling Jo and Madison four eyes.
- Monster High dolls: Catherine lost them for calling her older sisters names.
- Rock 'N' Roll Elmo: Robert lost it for blowing a raspberry at Gina and Jo.
- Elmo's World Birthdays, Games, and More DVD: Robert lost it for escaping from the Naughty Blanket.
- Chatters Elmo plush: Mike lost it for not sharing with Robert.
- Big Bird plush: Mike lost it for putting a whoopee cushion on a chair McDonald's.
- Ernie plush: Robert lost it for putting a whoopee cushion on a chair at McDonald's.
- Abby Cadabby plush: Catherine lost it for knocking over chairs at Wendy's.
- Sesame Street Zoe plush: Victoria lost it for dancing on the table at Wendy's.
- Chase plush: ??? lost it
- Rubble plush: ??? lost it
- Jessicake doll: ??? lost it
- Zuma plush: ??? lost it
- Pinkie Pie plush: ??? lost it
- Diego plush doll: Robert lost it for throwing food at the cook at KFC.
- Bubblelisha doll: Catherine lost it for twerking on the tables at KFC.
- Lalaloopsy dolls: Victoria lost them for twerking on the tables with Catherine at KFC.
- Rocky plush: Mike lost it for stealing a bucket of chicken.
- Yoda plush: Gary lost it for throwing food with Robert at KFC.
- Bert plush: Mike lost it for saying Yadada and calling Gina sir.
- Barney plush: Gary lost it for destroying Catherine's sculpture.
- Skye plush: ??? lost it
- Elmo plush: ??? lost it
- Donatina's Donut Delights Cart: Catherine lost it for jumping on the couch.
- Donatina doll: Catherine lost it for jumping on the couch.
- Marshall plush: ??? lost it
- Random Paw Patrol Stuff: Mike, Robert, and Gary lost them for destroying their sisters' tea party.
- Legos: ??? lost them
Season 16
Hyatte Family
- Dora the Explorer doll ~ Reggie lost it for misbehaving
Sliwinski Family
- Darkwing Duck plush doll: ??? lost it
- Darkwing Duck DVDs: ??? lost them
- Jinafore Long doll: ??? lost it
- MP3 player: ??? lost it
- Polly Pocket: ??? lost it
- Kingdom Hearts game: ??? lost it
Rockcastle Family
- Spongebob Baseball beanbag doll: ??? lost it
- Spongebob Squarepants plush: ??? lost it
- Spongebob sprinkler: ??? lost it
- Ty Spongebob plush pineapple house: ??? lost it
- Toy Bubble Gun: ??? lost it
- Air Hogs R/C controlled plane: ??? lost it
Orr Family
- Tom Cat plush: ??? lost it
- Jerry Mouse plush: ??? lost it
- Angry Birds Knock on Wood game: ??? lost it
Rodriguez Family
- Pinky and Brain plush toys: ??? lost them
Season 17
O'Hara Family
Piaccasa Family
Tachibana Family
Crawford Family
- Popples Bubbles plush: Stephanie lost it for scratching Jaiden.
Miles Family
Wong Family
- Pinky mouse plushie: ??? lost it
Parkington Family
Season 18
Llewellyn Family
Withers Family
Season 19
Season 20
Fern Family
- PS4: ??? lost it
Season 21
Season 22
Season 23
Kyra Family
- Tanuki: Samantha lost it for showing her evil side by accident
- Woody Woodpecker plush doll: Samantha lost it for flipping out
- Azelf, Uxie, and Mesprit plushies: Samantha lost it for flipping out
- Mario and Yoshi plushies: Samantha lost it for refusing to go to bed
Season 24
- Pinky and the Brain plushies: ??? lost them
- Yakko, Wakko and Dot plushies: ??? lost them
Season 25
Cullen Family
- Dora the Explorer DVDs: Charlotte lost them for refusing to take a nap.
Season 26
- Princess Tiana doll: ??? lost it
- Cinderella doll: ??? lost it
- Merida doll: ??? lost it
- Princess Jasmine doll: ??? lost it
- Mulan doll: ??? lost it
- Pocahontas doll: ??? lost it
Season 27
Season 28
Season 29
Cake Family
- Barney plush: Freddo lost it for calling Molly a bad name.
- Rainbow Dash plush: Viola lost it for fighting over a toy with Allegra.
- Draculaura doll: Allegra lost it for fighting over a toy with Viola.
- Cookie Monster plush: Reed lost it for calling Jennifer a stupid stinky butt.
- Diego plush: Reed lost it for hitting one of his siblings.
- Geo plush: ??? lost it
- Strawberry Shortcake doll: Arietta lost if it for telling her father to kill himself at Walmart.
- Milli plush: Dot lost it for saying a mean message at her father at Walmart.
- Applejack plush: Nera lost it for saying a bad word at Walmart.
- Apollo plush: Solo lost it for calling Harmony a bad name at Walmart.
- Cowbella plush: Harmony lost it for calling Solo a bad name at Walmart.
- Mickey Mouse plush: Zydeco lost it for shoplifting a Ernie doll at Walmart.
- Mittens Fluff 'N' Stuff doll: ??? lost it
- Bea Spells-a-Lot doll: ??? lost it
- Crumbs Sugar Cookie doll: ??? lost it
- Jewel Sparkles doll: ??? lost it
- Peanut Big Top doll: ??? lost it
- Spot Splatter Splash doll: ??? lost it
- Pillow Featherbed doll: ??? lost it
- Dot Starlight doll: ??? lost it
- Blossom Flowerpot doll: ??? lost it
- Tippy Tumblelina doll: ??? lost it
- Berry Jars 'N' Jam doll: ??? lost it
- Patch Treasurechest doll: ??? lost it
- Sunny Side Up doll: ??? lost it
- Marina Anchors doll: ??? lost it
- Misty Mysterious doll: ??? lost it
- Sahara Mirage doll: ??? lost it
- Peppy Pom Poms doll: ??? lost it
- Ace Fender Bender doll: ??? lost it
- Lady Stillwaiting doll: ??? lost it
- Sir Battlescarred doll: ??? lost it
- Cleo De Nile doll: Allegra lost it for fighting over a doll with Celesta.
- Zuma plush: Reed lost it for pooping on the floor.
Season 30
Season 31
- Puzzles: ??? lost them
- Crayons: ??? lost it
- Nintendo 3TS XL: ??? lost it
- Pirate ship: ??? lost it
- XBOX One: ??? lost it
- iPod Nano: ??? lost it
- Polly Pocket: ??? lost it
- Cell phone: ??? lost it
- LEGOs: ??? lost them
- Candyland board game: ??? lost it
- MP3 player: ??? lost it
- coloring book: ??? lost it
- Pinkie Pie plush: ??? lost it
- Mario plush: ??? lost it
- Operation board game: ??? lost it
- Guess Who game: ??? lost it
- Don't Wake Daddy game: ??? lost it
- The Logo Board Game: ??? lost it
- Lucky Ducks game: ??? lost it
Rodkins Family
- Super Why doll: ??? lost it
- Super Why DVD: ??? lost it
- Apple White doll: ??? lost it
Season 32
Season 33
Season 34
Cloud Family
- Baby Annabell dolls: ??? lost them
- Pinkie Pie plush: ??? lost it
- My Little Pony Friendship is Magic coloring book: ??? lost it
- Twilight Sparkle plush: ??? lost it
- Fluttershy plush: ??? lost it
- Rainbow Dash plush: ??? lost it
- Applejack plush toy: ??? lost it
- DJ Pon plush toy: ??? lost it
- Princess Luna plush: ??? lost it
- Dr. Hooves plush doll toy: ??? lost it
Season 35
- Nature Cat plush: Joshua lost it for spitting Haylee's Mr. Bilk plush.
- Daniel Tiger plush: Joshua lost it for ruining Haylee's 11th birthday party.
- Mission Chase: Joshua lost it for drawing on the walls.
- PBS Kids Start your Engines DVD: Joshua lost it for shoplifting a Super Why DVD.